Esmeralda Wants Her Money Back

The 1040NR – It looks slightly different now.

So Esmeralda came barging into the office the other day stating that she had wanted her money back and that she was expecting to get it all back. “Why did they keep my money, I’m not an American and I want my money back – you know how much $30 000 USD is to a Canadian right now?” “Yes, Esmeralda, I know – I also know that if you had it all for the next big Lotto 649 you would stand a better chance of winning. Anyhow, it sounds like you want to file the 1040NR.”

In order to get your money back – there is a process that you must follow. First you need to apply for an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN). You can actually apply for it and do the tax return at the same time. It has actually been my experience that most people actually apply for the ITIN first as they often want their money back before the next filing season begins. For you to get your ITIN you must fill out a form called the W-7 and provide “certified true copies” of the requested documentation. It is crucial that the copies provided with your W-7 are “certified true copies” as documents that have been certified by someone other than the issuing agency will not be accepted – this will most likely cause your application to be delayed or rejected altogether. For those of you who like to do it yourself – the form and instructions can be found on the official IRS website. Once the number has been provided by the IRS you can go ahead and file your tax return – there is even a special place for Canadians (Section 10 on page 4 of the 1040NR) as they pay taxes on their “net winnings” – it is like you expense the money that was lost in order to achieve the winnings. In the end, you will only pay a little bit of tax unless you didn’t lose anything. However, the IRS may want to see documented proof of your losings. “Document your losses, how the heck do you do that?”Esmeralda was furious when she was told that. There will be a list below of what could be considered documentation for poker games as well as other types of gambling. Many people are surprised that the IRS would ask for documentation of losses, but according to the IRS as a source once stated “If it isn’t documented, it didn’t happen”.

Some potential documentation that is kept by gamblers is the following:

Poker and other table games: You must record the name of the Casino, the number of the table that you played at – the casino credit card data, and if it applies, you must indicate if the credit was issued at the cashier’s cage or in the pit.

Slot machines: Record along with the location of the casino, the slot machine number and the times and dates that you won.

Lotteries: You must record the name, date, all tickets – including the losing ones, how much was paid and what was the result of each ticket (win or lose).

Dog or Horse Racing: It is important to record the times and dates of the actual races and the numbers of the animals bid on along with the details and the results of each bet, and payment records provided by the racetrack.

Please keep in mind that the IRS will not always ask for the proof but it should be kept in case they would like to see it. As a result of this compliance, it is highly recommended that if you plan on gambling often, to join the casino’s frequent gambler club using the card to track your winnings and losses. At the end of your stay, you can request a printout of your gambling activities. Yes, you can actually track your gambling winnings.

Esmeralda was amazed and upset at the same time – “who knew that gambling would be so much … work?” This is what you have to do to keep your gambling compliant, along with having fun of course. “Well, maybe if gambling is this tedious, I’ll just buy revenue property instead”.

Next time, we will explain to Esmeralda, what will occur if she decides to buy a property in Nevada to rent out when she is not there to gamble.

Attention Green Card Holders

Do you have a current Green Card or even an expired Green Card? If the answer is yes to either one of these questions. Surprise! you are an American for tax purposes – this little surprise includes filing a 1040 (US tax return) and any other foreign reporting requirements such as an FBAR, Foreign Trust Return 3520 and 3520 A, the PFIC (8621) etc. This must be done yearly until you officially surrender your Green Card – it does not matter where in the world you reside. Please refer to paragraph three for the USCIS’s official position on this. American citizens in Canada find these requirements burdensome and sometimes annoying, as some Americans have told me – why do it to yourself?

The Green Card allows for permanent residency in the US and that includes the honor of all tax requirements and carries basically the same requirements and rights as the American Citizen. The United States is only one of two countries in the world that taxes on both Citizenship and Residency – the other being Eritrea. Holding a Green Card, expired or not is basically saying “look at me, I’m an American resident.”

“Еven if the USCIS no longer considers a Green Card to be valid (for immigration purposes), the tax-related obligations that come with it will continue to apply – until an official written statement from the USCIS confirms that the Green Card has been revoked or relinquished.”

In my next post – I will address the topic of relinquishing that Green Card.

Esmeralda’s American Holiday: What Happened in Vegas Followed Her Home

Our friend Esmeralda is a Canadian citizen who loves to gamble – she considers it her “retirement planning” and cannot live without it. “I love to play poker, I have some element of control, you know, it’s kind of like investing in mutual funds (MF’s) or real estate. I love the thrill, plus it is 100% tax exempt”. Esmeralda, is correct that her poker gambling is exempt, along with her other gambling such as her purchases of the weekly Lotto 649 or the night at her favorite slot machine – this is true IN CANADA, for Canadians. As you may or may not know, it is different for our American friends living in and gambling in Canada (more in a different post).

I remember talking to Esmeralda about her “strategic tax planning” and how she hasn’t had a trip in over 25 years. She had mentioned going to Vegas to kill two birds with one stone. “I want to travel and build wealth and this can all be accomplished by going to Vegas”.

She had enjoyed her trip except one minor detail – she was taxed on her poker winnings – she had a very good winning streak, the best in her life. Boy, she was mad as could be. “I win $100 000.00 and I only get to come back with $70 000.00, what the heck”, she was screaming at this point. “They take my money, they give me this stupid form (1042-S), and they expect me to be happy! How can I be happy?”

She did not like my explanation in the least – things are different in Vegas or anywhere else in the United States when people like to plan their retirement “Esmeralda style”. It is a fact that US sourced income from gambling and lotteries is fully taxable – with the exception of a few “exempt games”. “What are those games? I lost $30 000.00 and don’t like it”. For information and planning purposes the exempt games are: craps, blackjack, big-6 wheel, roulette, or baccarat. The general rule was a surprise to Esmeralda, as it is to many other gamblers from around the world. Non US persons (nonresident aliens) are generally subjected to a 30% tax with holdings on gross gambling winnings. Canadian citizens and residents are able to get some or all of this money back due to a special provision in the tax treaty – U.S. –Canada Tax Treaty Article XXII (3) – under the condition that they file a US return, the 1040NR. Canada’s relationship with the US is so special that there is a special place on the 1040NR just for us.

In my next post “Esmeralda Want’s Her Money Back”, I will explain to Esmeralda, how to go about recovering some or all of the money and what she should do if she gambles in the future – and knowing her – it is going to be sometime soon.